Review: "A Tide of Black Steel"

A Tide of Black Steel by Anthony Ryan
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

Anthony Ryan’s A Tide of Black Steel exceeded my expectations for what a grand fantasy novel should be. Despite being told from the perspectives of multiple characters—a narrative technique that can sometimes feel distracting—Ryan handles the character switches masterfully. Each chapter is lengthy enough to allow plenty of development and action, making the transitions smooth and engaging. Although the connection between the different story lines was initially challenging to piece together, the anticipation of seeing these characters' paths converge kept the story compelling.

Plot and Structure:
The plot is intricately woven through themes of political intrigue, honor, and sacrifice. Ryan expertly balances these elements, creating a narrative that is both complex and coherent. The structure of the book is logical, and while the climaxes lead to resolutions, some were pleasantly surprising and shocking, adding to the overall enjoyment of the story.

Character Analysis:
The character dynamics between Thera and Lynnea were among the most exciting and intriguing aspects of the book. Their unique origins and complementary skills make them a formidable pair, and their understanding of each other’s intentions adds depth to their partnership. Elvine is another standout character; her journey from her beginnings in the Covenant to her critical role in the story's conclusion is both compelling and satisfying.

Ruhlin's character arc is a powerful exploration of balance, sacrifice, and identity. His internal struggle with his "fire blood" and the burden of being called to something beyond his mortal nature is portrayed with nuance and depth. Radylf, on the other hand, represents the theme of freedom versus enslavement. Although he is technically free, he is as bound by his circumstances and obligations as the other characters, making him a complex and tragic figure.

Themes:
The book delves deeply into themes of sacrifice, honor, pride, betrayal, personal ambition, power, control, identity, and loyalty. Characters constantly balance their outward goals with their true thoughts, often hidden beneath layers of manipulation and secrecy. While some themes are more subtle, they all leave a lasting impact, resonating long after the book is finished. These themes, though set in a fantasy world, are timeless and relevant, echoing the complexities of the modern world.

World-Building:
Ryan’s world-building is immersive and well-developed. Although the fantasy names of people and places can be challenging at first, the world feels whole and vividly depicted. The nature of the world and its intricacies are gradually revealed, creating a clear and engaging picture that pulls the reader into the story.

Writing Style:
Ryan’s writing style is engaging, maintaining a steady pace throughout the book. Unlike some fantasy novels that can become long-winded, Ryan strikes the perfect balance between description and action, keeping the story moving while allowing room for the reader's imagination. His ability to leave certain elements to the imagination adds an additional layer of engagement.

Final Thoughts:
The Tide of Black Steel is poised to be a hit within the fantasy community, offering a rich and accessible narrative that can draw in a wide audience. While the book is complex enough to satisfy seasoned fantasy readers, it is also accessible enough for those new to the genre. If you’re on the fence or usually steer clear of fantasy, this novel is a great entry point—it’s just that good.

Thanks to NetGalley and Orbit for an ARC in exchange for a fair and honest review. 

Rating:
★★★★★ (5/5 stars)

View all my reviews